Comic Review: Detective Comics 2025 Annual #1 – Batman on the Trail, with Heart and Mind

In a world where annual comic book issues often feel like little more than filler to pad out the publishing calendar, Detective Comics 2025 Annual #1 proves that an “annual” can still be a place for a truly exceptional story. Al Ewing—known for his ability to delve deep into character psychology and his unpredictable storytelling—delivers not just a top-tier detective story with Batman in the lead role, but also a tale full of heart, humor, and thoughtful reflection.

“Batman, do not solve my murder” – A Title That Instantly Pulls You In

Right from the moment you read the title of the main story, you know this won’t be just another standard Joker chase. The plot begins in a sealed underground bunker, where Batman discovers a body… and a note instructing him not to solve the murder. This clever setup launches one of the most tightly constructed investigations seen in the DC Universe in recent years.

The story follows a three-act structure—each part illustrated by a different artist—which builds tension like a finely tuned thriller. The shifting art styles don’t disrupt the narrative; in fact, they emphasize the changing locations and emotional tones. The first act stuns with a classic, moody detective aesthetic; the second hits hard with bold colors and stylized visuals; and the third ties everything together in a satisfying conclusion. The sense of being immersed in a living, breathing Gotham is undeniable.

Ewing writes Batman as a flesh-and-blood detective—coldly analytical, yet still a man who can’t fully detach from his emotions. Themes like death, the wishes of the deceased, and the ethical boundaries even Batman shouldn’t cross are woven into the story with subtlety and weight.

Between England and Gotham – History, Culture, and Emotion

One of the biggest surprises is the setting of the first act—England, with all its medieval and early modern ambiance. References to the country’s history, books, and the digitization of knowledge create a rich layer that will delight not just Batman fans but also readers with a love of academia. You can feel that Ewing writes with both passion and knowledge, never forgetting that at its core, Batman is a story about the fight for justice.

The Second Story – Batmobile, a Kid, and the Shadow of the System

The second tale in the issue is short, simple, but absolutely charming. Batman helps a young boy from an underprivileged neighborhood dealing with the consequences of systemic neglect in education. It’s a warm, heartfelt story that shows Batman’s softer side—the one that sometimes gets lost beneath the darkness and intensity.

Does the kid ride in the Batmobile? Yes. Is it a bit of naive fan service? Maybe. But it works perfectly. Batman is shown here as an empathetic figure who can come down from the rooftops and actually talk to people—a version of him worth remembering.

Al Ewing – A Candidate for an Ongoing Series? Yes, Please.

Many readers are saying it loud and clear after reading this Annual: give Al Ewing a regular Batman series. And it’s hard to argue. His instinct for character, his ability to blend detective work with introspection and emotional depth, and his control of pacing and tone—all of it fits Detective Comics like a glove. His Batman thinks, analyzes, but also feels. That’s what makes this portrayal so compelling.

Summary:

Detective Comics 2025 Annual #1 is a true gem—a comic that reminds us why Batman as a character and Detective Comics as a title are so special. Ewing doesn’t just tell a great story—he understands Batman and lets him shine in every role: detective, warrior, and human being.

Pros:

+Excellent, multilayered main story with a masterful investigation

+Three-act structure with perfectly chosen artists for each segment

+Batman as both a detective and a man – a rich, full interpretation

+Refreshing setting and cultural references (England, history, books)

+Charming, heartfelt second story with an important social message

+Great pacing and a solid balance between action and narrative

Cons:

– The second story, though lovely, feels a bit lightweight next to the main one

– Shifting art styles might throw off readers less used to visual variety

– The story leaves you wanting more – though that’s more of a compliment than a flaw