Comic Review: Detective Comics #1089 – Farewell to Gotham Nocturne
Ram V concludes his monumental saga in Detective Comics #1089, and he does it with grace, tenderness, and a deep understanding of not only Batman as a character but also the comic book medium itself. This isn’t just another story finale — it’s a reckoning with the myth of Batman, the cyclical nature of superhero storytelling, and even our own attachment to these characters. And while the ending hurts — because we’re saying goodbye to one of the most literary Batman runs in recent memory — it’s the kind of pain that feels just right.
Batman who doesn’t fight to win, but to never lose
Ram V deliberately moves away from the now-popular narrative of Batman as a symbol of hope. Instead, he offers something deeper: a character who doesn’t reject his darkness, but learns to live with it. Batman doesn’t need to “grow past” the darkness — he needs to coexist with it, and that’s what makes him truly human. In this narrative, Gotham isn’t just a city. It’s a living entity, a reflection of Bruce’s psyche, of his relationship with the past and present.
It’s a moving meditation on how a person — and a city — can endure, despite pain, loss, and compromise. Because, as one of the key lines in this issue states:
“We all need someone who’ll stand by and watch us lose our fights, don’t we?”
The art of ending without an ending
Some may say the ending feels rushed, but that’s part of its strength. Ram V doesn’t pretend this story has a final conclusion. Batman will keep fighting — that’s his nature. It’s not about winning. It’s about continuity. This final issue ties up the storylines that have been building for months, but it doesn’t slam the door shut — it lets the characters and their stories keep breathing.
The true faces of heroes and villains
Every character shines in this comic — even those usually in the background. Cass and Azrael try to save Bruce, Freeze betrays them for his own reasons, Bruce still appeals to his love for Nora. Every decision flows from character, not from plot necessity. A special shout-out to Talia and Selina, who are not written here as rival love interests, but as fully independent, fleshed-out individuals.
The backup stories by Dan Watters and Si Spurrier are gems — the Two-Face story might be one of the best takes on the character in years. I sincerely hope their names appear next to Ram V’s in bold in the collected edition.
Time as a narrative device
But maybe the biggest strength of this run isn’t just what it says, but how it says it. Gotham Nocturne felt like a symphony — structured in acts, motifs, and intermezzos, crafted with precision and narrative clarity. Reading this series over more than a year felt like living in this version of Gotham. Growing attached to its slow rhythm, its melancholy, its poetry. That’s exactly why this goodbye stings so deeply.
Visual artistry – many hands, one vision
Though many artists worked on this series, the whole thing surprisingly holds together. The art style captures Gotham’s dark, almost gothic tone and complements the drama of the story perfectly. The color work enhances the emotion, and the panel compositions feel like scenes from a play — carefully arranged, full of meaning.
In conclusion...
This run doesn’t change Batman forever. But it deeply understands Batman, loves Batman, and concludes its arc with honesty and beauty. Ram V and his team didn’t reinvent the character — they simply showed us how to tell a Batman story that’s mature, aware, and full of heart.
We say goodbye to this version of Detective Comics, knowing the story continues. But this act — this chapter — was something special. And one we’ll definitely want to return to.
Pros:
+Deep psychological portrayal of Batman
+Excellent depiction of female characters
+Backup stories that are just as crucial as the main plot
+Visuals and colors that match the emotional tone
Cons:
-The final issue may feel too fast-paced for some-Requires familiarity with previous issues to fully appreciate
My Score: 9.5/10
Detective Comics: Gotham Nocturne isn’t just a great Batman story — it’s a meditation on storytelling itself, on cycles, on how we live with our own darkness. Ram V shows us that Batman doesn’t always have to save the city. Sometimes, he just needs to be present for it. And that might be the most hopeful thing of all.
No comments